In Your Business Story, The AI-Enabled Experts Will Be The Heroes

Read this article on LinkedIn.
Where is the imminent mass unemployment from companies deploying AI? While job growth continues, the fear is very real. Some of it comes from Anthropic's early statements about AI possibly wiping out 30 to 50 percent of jobs. Some come from headlines of companies firing whole departments. Both these sources require re-examination. Anthropic's more recent research offers much more humble claims on the impact of AI on the workforce, and companies that were too heavy-handed with firing are now quietly walking those decisions back.
Not only is the job apocalypse overstated in the short run, but AI actually has tremendous career upside for the experts at your company. Further, we believe that the overall employment attrition won’t be nearly as bad as most people fear. Here are some blind spots general consensus has overlooked.
The Challenge of Predicting Job Growth in the Face of AI Disruption
This isn't the first time an entire profession was supposed to go extinct. Radiologists were supposed to be obsolete by now. Geoffrey Hinton, one of the fathers of neural networks, said as much 10 to 15 years ago. And while AI has gotten very good at reading X-rays and MRIs since then, the number of radiologists has gone up, not down.
Now the four horsemen have supposedly come for software engineers. Their work has become largely augmented and even automated by AI, and demand continues to grow, albeit more slowly, but it has not been the bloodbath public discourse would have you imagine. Zoom out, and overall it's still growing. Zoom out still further and total employment in the US is roughly 30 million higher than it was at the peak of the dotcom boom, despite two decades of technological disruption.
While other professions have indeed gone the way of the dodo (telephone operators, newspaper deliverers) or have been greatly reduced (travel agents, bank tellers), it's difficult to predict which jobs will stay, which ones will evolve, and what new job opportunities will be created.
Some jobs will evolve. The advent of productivity tools like Powerpoint and Excel shifted work from specialists to all knowledge workers, adding substantial new activity and job scope. With AI, computer programming has evolved into a highly productive supervisory role where engineers focus on high-level system architecture, cross-functional design, orchestration, and complex debugging. Nevertheless, the human stays firmly in the loop, now operating with vastly more leverage.
Finally, new jobs will emerge. It's easy to count what AI destroys, but hard to count what it creates. Ecommerce, for example, gutted physical retail jobs, but nobody was ready for how much it grew warehousing, delivery, and digital marketing. The losses were visible in advance, but the gains weren't, because the jobs didn't exist yet. We’ve already seen high growth in “red teaming” – people who are employed to quality check foundation models – that did not exist in 2021. The doom and gloom of the AI job-pocalypse ignores the new roles that will rise from the ashes of the to-be defunct positions.
Your Experts Are The Heroes
The implications of new technology on the workforce are particularly difficult to predict, but there is one clear way that you can prepare your organization for the age of AI: equip your experts.
The top 1 percent of performers in a given role are already 50 to 170 percent more productive than the average worker, depending on how complex the job. The more complex the job, the bigger that gap. AI is going to massively increase this gap. Managing agents adds complexity to any job and managing agents, rather than people, allows someone near infinite leverage.
Unfortunately, the people who should be adopting AI fastest can be the ones resisting it. You are seemingly asking your most senior, most identity-invested people to hand their knowledge to a machine. Framed incorrectly by leadership, it is that. Framed correctly, it's the opposite: you're the only one qualified to supervise, correct, and be accountable for what the agent does, which makes you more essential, not less.
Your experts already account for significantly more productivity in your org than the rest of your workforce. They are your most valuable resource.
The Story You Need To Tell
As a leader in a business, the roles in your company fall into three categories:
A) Limited impact: AI helps with some admin work, but no threat to job security.
B) Copilot: AI makes the role significantly more productive. The job evolves.
C) Autopilot: AI genuinely replaces the work in the near term. The job disappears.
For most companies and most roles, A and B cover almost everyone. C might occur for jobs in some organizations, but it's likely a small population today. Nevertheless, be upfront and communicate with empathy.
In this transition to the AI-enabled workforce, managing trust in the organization is the single- most important thing for you to do. Communicate what will change, but, just as important, communicate what won't. While disruption and innovation are exciting, they also bring instability, uncertainty, and fear. Focusing on what won't change in the business is essential for your people to feel steady. In terms of communicating what will change, paint a picture of the “point of arrival” that is inspirational for the company and your people: those that embrace AI can learn leading edge general technology that is changing the world and can become massively more impactful.
Personal growth and growth in impact is something that your most valuable employees should be excited about. Don’t let your employees stew in the soup of uncertainty. While no one can predict the future, there is a clear and compelling argument to be made that AI is the best thing to happen to your most valuable employees. That’s the story you need to tell.